Home > Topics > Business Organisation and Management > Co-operative Organization – Limitations & Types

Co-operative Organization – Limitations & Types

Every rose has thorns! Let's explore co-operative challenges and varieties.

Limitations/Disadvantages

1. Limited Capital

  • Depends on members only
  • Poor members → Poor co-operative
  • Example: Small farmers' co-operative can't generate ₹100 crores!

2. Inefficient Management

  • Elected managers may lack skills
  • Politics over merit
  • Example: Society elections → Popular but incompetent member wins!

3. Lack of Secrecy

  • Open book management
  • Competitors know everything
  • Example: Accounts audited & published → Rivals see strategies!

4. Conflict Among Members

  • Different interests
  • Rich vs poor members
  • Example: Big farmers want bulk sales, small farmers want retail!

5. Government Interference

  • Excessive regulation
  • Bureaucratic delays
  • Example: Need govt approval for every major decision → Slow!

6. Lack of Motivation

  • No direct profit link
  • Example: Member working less → Still gets same vote & benefit!

7. Limited Scope for Expansion

  • Can't raise funds like companies
  • Geographic limitations
  • Example: Village co-operative can't go national!

Detailed Types of Co-operatives

1. Consumer Co-operatives

Purpose: Buy in bulk, sell to members at lower prices

Examples:

  • Kendriya Bhandar
  • NCCF (National Co-operative Consumers' Federation)
  • Apna Bazaar

How it works:

  1. Members pay membership fee
  2. Co-operative buys goods wholesale
  3. Sells to members at cost price + small margin
  4. Members save money!

2. Producer Co-operatives

Purpose: Small producers unite to produce efficiently

Examples:

  • Handloom co-operatives
  • Khadi & Village Industries

Benefits:

  • Shared machinery
  • Better quality control
  • Collective branding

3. Marketing Co-operatives

Purpose: Help members sell products at better rates

Examples:

  • AMUL: Milk marketing
  • NAFED: Agricultural produce

How AMUL works:

  1. Farmers supply milk daily
  2. AMUL processes (butter, cheese, ice cream)
  3. Markets nationwide
  4. Profit shared with farmers!

4. Credit/Banking Co-operatives

Purpose: Provide cheap credit to members

Examples:

  • Saraswat Bank
  • District Co-operative Banks
  • Primary Agricultural Credit Societies (PACS)

Benefits:

  • Low interest: 8-10% (vs 24%+ by moneylenders!)
  • Easy loans for agriculture, small business
  • No collateral for small amounts

5. Housing Co-operatives

Purpose: Provide affordable housing

Examples:

  • Thousands across Mumbai, Pune, Delhi!

How it works:

  1. Members pool money
  2. Buy land collectively
  3. Build apartments
  4. Maintain society together

Benefits:

  • Cheaper than market rates
  • Joint ownership
  • Self-management

6. Farming Co-operatives

Purpose: Collective farming for better yields

Examples:

  • Sugarcane co-operatives in Maharashtra
  • Milk co-operatives in Gujarat

Benefits:

  • Shared equipment (tractors, harvesters)
  • Bulk buying of seeds, fertilizers
  • Collective bargaining

Co-operative Success Story: AMUL's White Revolution

Background

1946: Sardar Patel noticed farmers exploited by middlemen in Gujarat

Solution

1946: Formed Kaira District Co-operative Milk Producers' Union (later AMUL)

How it Changed India

  1. Direct procurement: Farmers → AMUL (no middlemen!)
  2. Fair prices: Farmers got 75%+ of consumer rupee
  3. Processing: Milk → Butter, Cheese Ice Cream
  4. Marketing: "Utterly Butterly Delicious" campaigns
  5. Result: India became world's largest milk producer!

Impact Today

  • 2.36 lakh farmers directly benefit
  • ₹38,000+ crore annual turnover
  • Model replicated across India!

Quiz

Test Your Knowledge

Question 1 of 4

1. Biggest limitation of co-operative is:

Unlimited liability
Limited capital
Too many taxes
Not democratic

💡 Final Wisdom: "Co-operatives prove that when people unite for a common cause, even the smallest can become the mightiest – just ask AMUL!"

← PreviousNext →