Limitations of Mutual Funds – Market Risks & Charges
Introduction
Mutual funds are not perfect. Like any investment, they come with risks and costs. A smart investor must understand the limitations before investing. Let's explore the key drawbacks.
1. Market Risk (No Guaranteed Returns)
Problem: MF returns are market-linked
Unlike:
- FD: 6.5% guaranteed
- PPF: 7.1% guaranteed
- MF: Can give -20% or +20% (depends on market)
Example:
- 2008 Financial Crisis: Equity funds fell 50%
- 2020 COVID Crash: Nifty fell 38% in 1 month
- 2017 Bull Run: Equity funds gave 30%+ returns
Risk for Investors:
- Short-term volatility: Can see losses in any year
- Not suitable for emergency funds (might be in loss when you need money)
Loading diagram…
2. High Expense Ratio (Ongoing Charges)
What is Expense Ratio? Annual fee charged by AMC (deducted from NAV daily)
Components:
- Fund manager salary
- Research team costs
- Marketing expenses
- Custodian fees
- Registrar charges
Typical Expense Ratios:
- Equity Funds: 1.5% - 2.5%
- Debt Funds: 0.5% - 1.5%
- Index Funds: 0.1% - 0.5% (lowest)
Impact on Returns:
Loading comparison…
Loss: ₹2 lakh over 20 years due to higher expense ratio!
3. Fund Manager Dependency
Risk: If star fund manager leaves, performance may suffer
Example:
- Prashant Jain left HDFC MF (2022)
- Investors worried about future returns
- Many redeemed units
Problem:
- Past performance due to specific manager's skill
- New manager may have different strategy
- "Manager risk" is real
4. Dilution (Too Much Money)
Problem: When a fund becomes too large (₹50,000+ Cr AUM)
Challenges:
- Hard to enter/exit large positions (₹5,000 Cr in one stock?)
- Restricted to large-cap stocks only (can't buy small-caps)
- Returns may moderate (harder to beat index)
Example:
- Small fund (₹500 Cr): Can invest in 100 companies (including small-caps)
- Large fund (₹50,000 Cr): Forced to buy only Nifty 50 stocks
5. No Control Over Portfolio
Problem: You can't decide which stocks the fund buys
Scenario:
- You love Tech sector, hate Pharma
- But your MF holds 15% in Pharma (fund manager's call)
- You have no control
vs Direct Equity:
- You choose exactly which stocks to buy
- MF: Fund manager decides
6. Exit Load (Penalty on Early Withdrawal)
What is Exit Load? Charge for redeeming units within a certain period
Typical Structure:
- Redeem within 1 year: 1% exit load
- Redeem after 1 year: Nil
Example:
- Invested ₹1,00,000
- Redeem after 6 months (value now ₹1,10,000)
- Exit load: 1% of ₹1,10,000 = ₹1,100 (deducted)
- Net proceeds: ₹1,08,900
Impact: Reduces liquidity benefit
7. Tax on Gains
Equity Funds:
- STCG (< 1 year): 15%
- LTCG (> 1 year): 10% on gains above ₹1 lakh
Debt Funds:
- Taxed at slab rates (up to 30%)
Problem: Unlike PPF/EPF (tax-free), MF gains are taxable
8. Over-Diversification
Problem: Too many funds = Diluted returns
Scenario:
- Investor buys 10 different equity funds
- All hold same stocks (Reliance, HDFC, Infosys)
- No real diversification, just duplication
- High expense ratio (10 funds × 2% each)
Better: 2-3 well-chosen funds across categories
9. Lock-in Period (ELSS)
ELSS (Tax Saving Funds):
- 3-year lock-in (mandatory)
- Cannot redeem even in emergency
vs Other MFs:
- Open-ended: Redeem anytime
- ELSS: Wait 3 years
10. Fluctuating NAV (Volatility Stress)
Problem: Daily NAV changes cause anxiety
Example:
- Monday: NAV = ₹50
- Friday: NAV = ₹48 (-4% in 1 week)
- Investor panics and sells
Emotional Trap:
- Seeing portfolio value drop triggers fear
- Panic selling at wrong time
- Solution: Long-term view (ignore daily NAV)
Summary: Limitations Table
| Limitation | Impact | Who Should Worry? |
|---|---|---|
| Market Risk | Can give negative returns | Short-term investors |
| Expense Ratio | 1-2.5% annual cost | All investors (choose low-cost) |
| Fund Manager Risk | Performance drops if manager leaves | Large investors |
| No Control | Can't choose stocks | Control freaks |
| Exit Load | 1% penalty if redeem early | Short-term traders |
| Tax | 10-15% on gains | High-return funds |
| Over-Diversification | Diluted returns | Those with 10+ funds |
| ELSS Lock-in | 3-year mandatory | Emergency funds |
| NAV Volatility | Daily ups/downs | Emotionally weak investors |
Comparison: MF vs Other Investments
| Feature | Mutual Funds | Fixed Deposits | Direct Equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Returns | Market-linked (variable) | Guaranteed (6-7%) | Market-linked (high variance) |
| Risk | Moderate (diversified) | Very Low | High (stock-specific) |
| Charges | 1-2.5% p.a. | Nil | Brokerage only |
| Control | None (FM decides) | N/A | Full control |
| Liquidity | 1-3 days | Penalty on early withdrawal | Instant (T+2) |
Exam Notes: Writing the Answer
Question: "Critically examine the limitations of mutual funds." (10 Marks)
Answering Structure:
- Introduction: "While MFs have many advantages, they also have limitations..."
- 10 Limitations: List and explain (Market Risk, Expense Ratio, etc.)
- Examples: 2008 crash (-50%), Expense ratio impact on 20-year return
- Conclusion: "Investors must understand these drawbacks before investing"
Quiz Time! 🎯
Loading quiz…