Emotions & Financial Decision-Making

The Role of Emotions in Finance

Traditional finance assumes emotionless decision-making—pure logic, mathematical optimization.

Reality: Emotions powerfully influence financial choices:

• Fear drives panic selling
• Greed fuels bubble participation
• Regret causes paralysis
• Pride prevents admitting mistakes

Neuroscience Evidence: fMRI studies show financial decisions activate emotional brain regions (amygdala, insula) as much as cognitive regions (prefrontal cortex).

Key Emotions in Finance

Fear & Anxiety

Impact on Behavior:

• Flight response: Sell everything, move to cash
• Risk aversion amplification: Excessive caution after losses
• Tunnel vision: Focus only on threats, miss opportunities

Market Impact:

• Panic selling: March 2020 COVID crash, 2008 financial crisis
• Flight to safety: Flee equities → bonds/gold
• Overshooting: Fear-driven selling pushes prices below fair value

Evidence: VIX (fear gauge) spikes correlate with market bottoms—extreme fear creates buying opportunities.

Indian Example: Demonetization announcement (Nov 8, 2016)—Nifty fell 6% in one day on fear/uncertainty. Within 2 months, fully recovered. Fear = temporary mispricing.

Greed & Overexuberance

Impact on Behavior:

• FOMO (Fear of Missing Out): Jump into rising markets
• Risk-seeking: Chase high returns, ignore risks
• Overtrading: Active management, frequent churning

Market Impact:

• Bubbles: Everyone wants in (dotcom 2000, housing 2006, crypto 2017)
• Overvaluation: Greed pushes prices far above fundamentals
• Crashes: When greed exhausts (no new buyers), collapse

Evidence: Investor sentiment surveys at market peaks show extreme optimism (80%+ bulls)—contrarian sell signal.

Indian Context: 2007-2008 bull run—retail investors opened record demat accounts, IPOs oversubscribed 50-100x. Greed-driven peak. Then 2008 crash.

Regret

Anticipated Regret: Fear of regretting a decision influences choices.

Two Types:

• Regret of commission (doing something that fails)
• Regret of omission (not doing something that succeeds)

Investment Impact:

• Paralysis: Avoid decisions that might cause regret
• Disposition effect: Sell winners (avoid regret of losing gains), hold losers (avoid regret of realizing loss)
• Herd following: "If I follow crowd and lose, less regret than losing alone"

Example: Investor hesitant to sell losing stock because selling = admitting mistake = regret. Holds hoping to avoid regret, accumulating bigger losses.

Pride & Overconfidence

Self-Attribution Bias:

• Successes → "I'm skilled!"
• Failures → "Bad luck!"

Result: Inflated self-assessment, overconfidence.

Investment Impact:

• Overtrading: "I can beat the market"
• Underdiversification: "I know these few stocks well"
• Excessive risk: "This leveraged bet will work"

Evidence: Men trade 45% more than women (overconfidence from testosterone), underperforming by 1.4% annually as a result (Barber & Odean).

Emotional Cycles & Market Dynamics

Bull Market Emotional Progression:

• Optimism → Stocks rising moderately
• Excitement → Gains accelerate, more buyers enter
• Thrill → Everyone's making money, FOMO intense
• Euphoria → "Can't lose!" Peak greed, maximum risk
• [PEAK]

Bear Market Emotional Progression:

• Anxiety → First declines, uncertainty
• Denial → "Just a correction, will bounce back"
• Fear → Losses mounting, panic brewing
• Desperation → "Make it stop!"
• Panic → Sell everything!
• [BOTTOM]
• Capitulation → Give up on stocks
• Despondency → "Stocks are dead"
• Hope → Maybe recovery possible
• Relief → Losses recovering
• Optimism → Cycle repeats

Measuring & Managing Emotions

Sentiment Indicators (Emotional Proxies)

VIX: Fear/volatility index

• VIX > 30: High fear
• VIX < 15: Complacency

Put/Call Ratio: Bearish vs bullish options Fund Flows: Money into/out of stock funds (greed/fear) Investor Surveys: % bulls vs bears

Contrarian Use: Extreme emotions = reversal signals.

Emotional Regulation Strategies

Pre-Commitment Rules:

• "Rebalance annually on January 1, regardless of feelings"
• "Never sell in a panic (wait 48 hours)"
• "Maximum 10% in any single stock"

Benefit: Removes emotions from decision point.

Automation:

• SIPs → Remove market-timing emotion
• Auto-rebalancing → Remove fear/greed from rebalancing
• Robo-advisors → Eliminate emotional override

Mindfulness & Awareness:

• "Am I deciding based on fear?" (Self-check)
• Keep investment journal: "Why am I buying/selling?"
• Review during calm periods: "Was that fear rational?"

Social Support:

• Investment clubs → Peer accountability
• Financial advisors → Emotional ballast during volatility
• Mentorship → Experienced investors provide perspective

Neurofinance Insights

Brain Regions:

• Amygdala: Fear, panic
• Nucleus accumbens: Reward, greed
• Anterior insula: Pain of losses
• Prefrontal cortex: Rational analysis

Findings:

• Losses activate pain centers 2.5x more than equivalent gains activate pleasure (loss aversion neurologically confirmed)
• Under stress, prefrontal cortex (rationality) shuts down, lia (fear) dominates → Panic decisions
• Testosterone correlates with overtrading (biological overconfidence)

Implication: Emotions aren't just "irrational noise"—they're hardwired neurological responses. Can't eliminate, but can manage through awareness and rules.

---

Key Takeaways

• Emotions dominate: Fear, greed, regret, pride powerfully influence financial decisions
• Fear: Drives panic selling, creates buying opportunities (VIX spikes = market bottoms)
• Greed: Fuels bubbles, FOMO, leads to crashes when exhausted
• Regret: Causes paralysis, disposition effect (avoid selling losers)
• Pride/overconfidence: Leads to overtrading, under-diversification
• Emotional cycles: Bull markets progress optimism → euphoria; bear markets anxiety → panic → capitulation
• Management: Pre-commitment rules, automation, sentiment monitoring, self-awareness
• Neuroscience: Confirms loss aversion (~2.5x), stress shuts down rationality
• Contrarian principle: Trade against extreme emotions (buy panic, sell euphoria)

---

Loading quiz…