Problems in Construction of Index Numbers 🚧

Constructing an Index Number isn't just about math; it requires making several crucial decisions. If these choices are wrong, the Index Number becomes useless.

1. Defining the Purpose 🎯

First, we must ask: "Why are we making this index?"

• An index for "Wholesale Prices" cannot be used to measure the "Cost of Living" for a factory worker. The items and weights would be completely different.

2. Selection of Base Year 📅

The base year is the benchmark.

• Normal Year: It must be a year of stability (no war, famine, economic crash).
• Not too distant: A base year of 1950 is useless for comparing prices in 2024 because consumption habits have changed entirely.

3. Selection of Items (Regimen) 🛒

We can't include everything. We must select a representative sample.

• Items should be standardized and graded (e.g., standard "Wheat" price, not random quality).
• Must represent the habits of the people concerned.

4. Selection of Prices 💲

• Wholesale vs Retail: Wholesale prices are stable; Retail prices vary from shop to shop. We must decide which to use.
• Data Source: Prices must be collected from reliable, standard sources.

5. Selection of Weights ⚖️

Not all items are equally important.

• Rice & Wheat are more important than Salt & Pepper.
• We need a system of "Weighting" to reflect this importance. Without weights (Unweighted Index), a 100% rise in Salt price would affect the index as much as a 100% rise in Rice price, which is wrong.

6. Selection of Formula ⚗️

There are many mathematical methods (Laspeyres, Paasche, Fisher, etc.).

• We must choose the one that gives the most consistent and accurate results for our purpose.
• Fisher’s Ideal Index is statistically best but difficult to calculate.

Summary Table 📋

Summary

Constructing an index is a series of choices. The quality of the index depends on the wisdom of these choices, especially the Base Year and Weights.

Loading quiz…